Reports menu

The Future of Healthcare

Q4 2023 Commentary

Going forward, we will sub-categorise the companies we follow under the theme of the Future of Healthcare in one of the following sub-categories: 

Biotech & Drug Discovery

Despite companies such as GSK (having divested its consumer health business Haleon) proclaiming its dedication to “preventing and treating disease”, larger pharma companies still tend to be very selective (and not particularly successful) in developing new therapies, and often end up buying in late-stage projects. This can create enormous rewards for the biotech companies that have developed them, but it can be a long wait. And there are few immediate signs of that changing. 

 

Drug development remains time consuming and laborious, despite the claims that Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming Research & Development (R&D). There is no way to avoid the need to move from in silico to in vitro then animal then human trials, whilst cash is drained along the way. Licensing deals with large companies can promise very substantial milestones and royalties but offer no assurance that development will proceed and the market will apply a very substantial discount rate to them. We have seen a few encouraging signs with milestone payments being unlocked in a few cases. FDA approval of Casgevy late last year is very positive for Maxcyte’s many strategic platform licences, for example, and C4X Discovery now seems to be well on the way to realising the potential of some of their developments, as does Scancell.  

 

Sentiment in the US should have helped, as the Nasdaq Biotech index rebounded about 10% in Q4, but there was little follow-through and concerns around funding requirements against a background of outflows from AIM-specialist funds (i.e. meaning that there were no natural buyers for new shares) weighed the sector down. Having a “big brother” shareholder (as Scancell and Redx have with Redmile) can be helpful.  

 

Companies across AIM are still generally trading at substantial discounts to the (already heavily discounted) valuations analysts are placing on their portfolios. Companies are being much more careful to conserve funds and to choose which projects to invest in than in previous years. They are seeking to prioritise “business development” (i.e. looking for partners) and we would hope to see some more evidence of consolidation in the sector.  

Medtech & Diagnostics

There is huge potential for more sophisticated diagnostic tools to be used to catch disease earlier, and realise substantial savings to health systems, public or private. Many tests – e.g. the UK standard test to predict cardiovascular disease – are simplistic in the extreme. Companies working in this field are using machine learning (which they usually call AI) to crunch large datasets to improve prediction, and polygenic information to try to identify vulnerable patient groups. Interestingly, the ethical concerns on this which were heard a few years ago seem to have become less strident as the obvious health gains have become more obvious. As well as aiding prevention, tests can also be used to determine which patients will benefit from particular therapies.  

 

As with everything in medicine, there are regulatory and bureaucratic hurdles to overcome. In the US, FDA approval is a necessary but not sufficient (as Angle found in 2022), and one whose timing cannot be predicted. Spending on building out marketing when the FDA is dilatory in granting permission can be cripplingly expensive, as Renalytix (now trading at 1% of its post Nasdaq-listing share price high) has found. Having substantial healthcare provider partners – as GENinCode has in Kaiser Permanente – is also not enough in itself. And when the hurdles are overcome, the ramp up of sales becomes a race against cash drain. 

 

Finding affordable routes to market will be vital, and Verici’s deal with Thermo Fisher (who intend to run the Verici tests on their machines) may well be imitated by other companies in the sector.  

Consumer Health

Routes to market are key in this area- and as Optibiotix found five years ago when they signed up with Holland and Barrett, a large partner with limited commitment can make very little difference. On the other hand, Futura’s partnership with Cooper for Europe (and through them to Boots) seems (we have yet to see hard numbers) to be delivering, and Haleon looks to be a terrific partner for the USA.  


Small companies can find themselves being the outsourced and unpaid R&D resources for larger ones. For example, Croda’s relationship with SkinBioTherapeutics for cosmetic use of SBTX’s lysates is very promising but Croda seems to be in no hurry to press on with it. 

 

With mass advertising and the use of influencers and social media, it is easy to see how new consumer health products can grow. The markets are enormous and growing (obesity driving many), but accessing them can be difficult. We continue to keep an eye out for opportunities in this area and look for signs of commercial breakthroughs.   

Click on the companies logos to access the latest updates

Biotech & Drug Discovery

Medtech & Diagnostics

Consumer Health

image_print